Ince ENGL 227 Project
jaredince
American witch literature can be
found rooted in the nightmarish witch trials of the seventeenth century. Such literature in this period
consisted of nonfiction writings on what were believed to be actual
occurrences. About 150 years
later, in the early nineteenth century, witches were adopted into American
fiction. All types of fiction
incorporated witches, from suspense to romance, and this created motley of
witch personas. As fiction
evolved, so did the stereotypes, until they became ingrained in modern
culture. This exhibit explores the
process of the aforementioned evolution, beginning in with a petition written
by alleged witches from Salem, Massachusetts, continuing to discuss the
emergence of American witch fiction, and culminating in a doctoral dissertation
written by a modern witch.
This petition was written in 1692 by alleged witches having been imprisoned for the winter and awaiting the renewal of their trials the following spring. The women beseeched their captors to allow them to winter on bail, for among them were many elderly widows and young women, either pregnant or already with infants. Knowing their innocence, they claimed themselves fearless of the spring trials; their only qualms were derived from the harsh winter and the unprotected conditions of their prison. This letter elucidates the other, oft overshadowed, side of the Salem Witch Trials. Rather than dwelling on the concepts of extreme religious zeal or mass hysteria, this petition shows the thoughts of the simple villagers caught amidst that tragedy and trying to survive into its aftermath. It is an important resource, as it shows the humanity in an event that happened over three centuries ago, and event often wondered at as a nightmare in American history. |
This painting, done almost two centuries after
the occurrence of its historical subject, details the drama of the Salem Witch
Trials. In the center of the room,
surrounded by a crowd of onlookers and watched by two judges, a man lies
unconscious or dead against a swooning woman. Another woman stands half stripped near the front of the
crowd, attempting to preserve what modesty remains to her. A third woman hazards her own life and
reputation by pleading with a judge for mercy towards the accused. The two judges sit nonchalantly,
impartially watching the scene before them while a guard attempts to prevent
additional spectators from entering the room. This scene mimics the many that actually took place during
the Trials. It captures the high
emotions and mob mentality of the crowd, but fails to include the judges in
this mass mania, an inclusion that most assuredly happened in many instances of
the Witch Hunts. |
The article, “New England Witchcraft in Fiction”, by G. Harrison Orions, discusses the early fiction of the literary witch craze, which emerged in the early nineteenth century. It explains the reasons for and the processes by which nineteenth century authors adapted the histories of the witch hunts to their own purposes. Orions shows that, by studying the birth of the modern American witch story and identifying the aspects recognizable to the 21st century reader, one might better understand the witch stereotypes and allusions found within modern fictional media. |
“Shadows of Doubt: Specter Evidence in Hawthorne’s “Young Goodman
Brown”, an article written by David Levin, which presents an interpretation of
the story counter to previous interpretive articles. Levin attempts to adopt a more outright interpretation of
the story, refusing to remove himself from the context of Hawthorne’s
culture. Levin states that Brown
is not justified in his judgments of the other villagers, as he is merely
realizing his own ability to be evil.
Levin says that the story is about Brown’s “discovery of the possibility of universal evil”. This new interpretation presents
Hawthorne’s story more as a philosophical treatise on the nature of evil than a
fantasy about witches. It shows
that fiction is merely a medium an author uses to express his own ideas, a
concept well used in the study of all literature.
|
“Signs, Cures, and Witchery:
Appalachian Cosmology and Belief” is a film review article written by Mathew Branch
which discusses the documentary, “Signs, Cures, and Witchery”, produced by
Gerald Milnes. The film discusses
the German and European folk beliefs of the Appalachian Mountains. Branch says that the film contains
interviews with elderly people who still practice these folk magics, erecting
simple charms and casting simple spells.
The film is said to portray these modern witches as a dying people, a
culture removed from the modern.
This review helps one understand the folk practices of a people who, in
the times of early American literature, might have been persecuted for their
beliefs; it allows one to begin to understand the social turmoil of America in
the 17th, 18th, and 19th centuries. |
"’SOMETHING WICKED THIS WAY COMES’: CONSTRUCTING THE WITCH IN CONTEMPORARY AMERICAN POPULAR CULTURE” is a dissertation for a doctorate of philosophy written by Catherine Armetta Shufelt and submitted in December of 2007. It discusses the modern ideology surrounding witches as well as explores and defends modern pagan religious practices. Shufelt seeks to dismantle the traditional western witch stereotypes by discussing modern Wiccan philosophies and by citing her own experiences as a Wicca. She details the use of witches in both fiction and nonfiction extending back to the middle ages and shows how witch stereotypes have formed and evolved over time. She discusses modern paganisms as earth based religions, giving examples of Wiccan nature based rituals and environmental political activism. Shufelt’s dissertation serves to bring early American witch literature into a modern, applicable light. |
Through the analysis of American literature, one can understand how certain literary stigmas develop over time. Through the analysis of witches in America’s literature, one can observe the development of the fictional witch, from its historical roots and into its modern home within fantasy and horror novels, and compare these characters to the real witches of the modern pagan religious movements. This allows one to gain a both a better understanding of America’s past and the ability to distinguish between the fiction and reality of modern culture.